Skip to content
BSG Carriers
800-799-3080Carrier LoginGet started
Equipment

Which trailer should you run? A comparison for owner-operators

Dry van, reefer, flatbed, power only, box truck and hotshot, compared on the things that actually decide it: what the freight is, what the rate has to cover, and what the work asks of you.

Dry vanReeferFlatbedPower onlyBox truckHotshot

There is no best trailer, only a best fit

Most equipment advice online ranks trailers as though one of them wins. None of them does. A reefer earns more per mile than a dry van and spends more to do it. A flatbed pays well and asks for physical work in weather. A hotshot has the lowest cost base and the smallest payload. The right answer depends on your capital, your home base, the hours you want and what you are willing to do at a dock.

What follows compares them on the things that actually decide it, with a link to the full page for each. No earnings figures appear anywhere, because any number printed here would be wrong for most of the trucks reading it within a week. The calculator on this site does the arithmetic with your own costs.

What each one hauls

Dry van

Anything palletised that needs no temperature control: packaged food, paper, consumer goods, building products. The deepest freight pool and the most competition.

Reefer

Produce in season, plus protein, dairy and frozen year round. Pays above dry van and carries temperature obligations and claim exposure that dry van does not.

Flatbed

Industrial freight: steel, lumber, pipe, machinery, building products. Pays for securement skill and tarping, and is less exposed to the retail cycle.

Power only

Somebody else’s trailer, usually drop-and-hook on a shipper or carrier pool. Lower rate, far lower cost base, and much less time spent at docks.

Box truck

Final mile, LTL overflow, expedited and local commercial freight. No CDL needed at 26,000 lb GVWR, and access to deliveries larger equipment cannot make.

Hotshot

Urgent and oversized-but-small: machinery, pipe, parts for a stopped line. Open deck on a one-ton with a gooseneck. Sells speed and access, not capacity.

What it costs to get in

Roughly in order of capital required, lowest first. Equipment prices move constantly, so no figures are quoted — this is the ordering, not the budget.

  • Box truck: the lowest barrier of the six. No CDL at 26,000 lb GVWR, no tractor, and a vehicle that can be parked more or less anywhere.
  • Hotshot: a one-ton and a gooseneck. Low by trucking standards, and no CDL if the combination is rated under 26,001 lb GCWR — though it is still a commercial operation with full compliance obligations.
  • Power only: a tractor and no trailer. The cheapest way into Class 8 work, because the box stays off your balance sheet.
  • Dry van: tractor plus a van. The standard starting point for a Class 8 owner-operator.
  • Flatbed: tractor plus a flat, plus several thousand dollars of straps, chains, binders, tarps and edge protection that people routinely forget to budget for.
  • Reefer: the highest. The trailer costs more, the unit needs servicing, and it burns its own fuel every hour it runs.

What the work actually asks of you

The part that decides whether you stay in it, and the part rate comparisons leave out.

  • Dry van: mostly drop-and-hook or dock waiting. Physically the easiest. Competes on price, so the pressure is on rate rather than on effort.
  • Reefer: temperature discipline and paperwork. Pre-cooling, set points, modes, downloads, washouts. Exacting rather than heavy.
  • Flatbed: securement and tarping, outdoors, in whatever weather there is. The most physical of the six, and the one where competence is most visibly rewarded.
  • Power only: the least time at docks, because the trailer is loaded before you arrive. You inspect equipment you did not load and carry interchange cover for it.
  • Box truck: frequent stops, liftgates, hand-loading and residential access. More deliveries per day than any of the others.
  • Hotshot: open-deck securement on smaller loads, plus the urgency that makes the freight worth taking at all.

The comparisons people actually search for

**Dry van or reefer.** A reefer can haul dry freight when the market is soft, so you have access to both pools — real optionality in a bad month. In exchange you carry a higher payment, reefer fuel, washouts and the claim exposure. If the rate premium does not cover all four, it is not a premium.

**Flatbed or step deck or RGN.** A standard flat handles most industrial freight. A step deck lowers the deck so taller loads stay legal without permits. An RGN is heavy-haul: higher rates, far fewer loads, permits and escorts as routine. Most carriers should start on a flat.

**Power only or owning a trailer.** Owning gives you access to every van load and the freedom to go anywhere. Power only gives you a lower cost base and less say. Plenty of carriers own a box and take power only work when it suits the week, which keeps both pools open.

**Box truck or hotshot.** They look similar on capacity and barely overlap in practice. A box is enclosed and suits palletised, final-mile and liftgate work; a hotshot is open-deck and suits machinery, pipe and building materials. Choose on the freight near you, not on the specification sheet.

Whichever you run, the arithmetic is the same

01
Work out your cost per mile
Including deadhead, and including the reefer unit or the tarps if you have them. Until you have this number, no rate can be judged.
02
Judge the round trip, not the leg
A strong rate into a market with nothing coming out of it loses to a moderate rate into one that reloads the same day. This is true of all six.
03
Read the rate confirmation before signing
Free time, detention, TONU, lumpers, tarp pay, accessorials. Every equipment type has its own version of the clause that costs you money.
04
Build toward repeat lanes
Consistency beats a good rate in every one of these markets. It is the single thing that most changes a year.

What it costs to have us dispatch it

Dispatching is charged as a percentage of the linehaul, agreed before you take your first load, and there is no long-term contract to sign. Ask a dispatcher for the current rate.

We dispatch all six. If you are switching equipment, say so when you call — the lanes, the brokers and the questions to ask all change with the trailer.

Where to go next

Dispatching for 53 ft dry vansThe most common trailer on the road, and the deepest freight pool.Reefer dispatchTemperature-controlled freight, produce season and FSMA paperwork.Flatbed dispatchSteel, lumber, machinery — and the securement that comes with them.Power only loadsYour tractor, their trailer. Drop and hook without buying a box.Box truck loads and ratesStraight trucks, final mile and freight that does not need a 53-footer.Hotshot dispatchClass 3 to 5 with a gooseneck, running expedited and partial loads.Dedicated lanesRepeat, consistent freight — the thing that matters most whichever trailer you pull.Cost per mile calculatorWork out your break-even before comparing any two of these on rate.Compare equipmentDry van, reefer, flatbed, power only, box truck and hotshot, side by side.How freight rates are setWhen each one pays better, judged against your own cost per mile.All dispatch servicesEverything we handle, from finding the load to chasing the invoice.Dispatch for owner-operatorsHow we work for a single truck, and what you keep control of.What the words meanThe words used around a load, explained without jargon.Articles for owner-operatorsDeadhead, detention and finding loads — the business of running a truck.
FAQ

Questions carriers ask

There is no single answer, and be sceptical of anyone who gives one. Reefer and flatbed generally price above dry van, and both cost more to run and ask more of you. What decides your year is your cost per mile, your deadhead and whether your lanes repeat — not which trailer is behind you.

Put your truck to work

Send your MC and DOT numbers and a dispatcher will call you within one business day.